History of Islam and the West
Create a visual representation of a history timeline for the period 600-2000 AD using the following milestones- 622-661_ Prophetic & Rashidun Period, 661-1066_ The High Caliphate Period , 1066-1500_ The Middle Period. Age of Sultanates, Emi.jpg

Who Writes History? 

History is not neutral. Conquerors will present history from their own viewpoint. The European global empires of the nineteenth century and today’s American empire are certainly no exceptions to this rule. A currently best-selling book on European history, The Penguin History of Europe by J. M. Roberts, is a good example of Eurocentric history writing. For example, the author dismisses the genocide and “virtual extinction” of the inhabitants of a whole continent (Native Americans) as “one of the costs of the opportunities which English America…offered to thousands of poor Europeans.”

Fortunately, in recent decades, more balanced and culturally respectful authors have emerged, though subtle biases sometimes persist which even the author may not perceive.

Create a representation from the attached image.jpg

Representation of J M Roberts, author or Penguin History of Europe

How is Islamic History portrayed?

The history of Islamic civilization is particularly skewed and full of distortions that go back to the Middle Ages. It is our job to rediscover and re-present our history in the way it deserves. Muslims led the world intellectually, culturally, and militarily for over a thousand years—until at least the 18th century. This great historical reality is fragmented in standard Western textbooks, often presented as many separate histories: those of the Moors, Arabs, Turks, Mughals, and Mongols, etc. The unity of the civilization is noted by only a few authors. In this way, the common ‘Islamic’ part of our history is downgraded and minimized. Often, we find the whole of Islamic history relegated to a few pages in a book on world history. It is time to reclaim and rename our history.

Reclaiming and Renaming History

Western textbooks generally divide recent human history into:

  • The Middle Ages (aka Medieval Period): from the end of the Western Roman Empire (c.476) to around 1500.
  • The Early Modern Period: from c.1500 to c.1800.
  • The Modern Period: from c.1800 to the present.

However, the author believes that the year 622 CE is such a pivotal year in human history that it would make more sense to start the Middle Ages from that point. 622 is Year 1 of the Islamic Calendar, marking the Emigration (Hijra) of the Messenger of God, Muhammad ﷺ. We designate it as the beginning of the 'Islamic Age', or 'Islamic Millennium'. The ‘Middle Ages’ are often seen in a negative light, an age in which Christian Europe was sunk in darkness and superstition. Eurocentrics tend to assume the whole world was in darkness. But in fact, this period was a golden age of the Islamic civilization, which spanned a large part of the world and was based on the supremacy of one book, the Quran. All Islamic empires and emirates throughout the Islamic Age have believed in the supremacy of the Quran, even if they often fell short of its lofty teachings. The laws of the land were always based on Shariah.

In our scheme, the Islamic Age, or Islamic Millennium, extends from the Hijra until 1707 CE (well into the Early Modern period). We mark 1707 as a symbolic end to the Islamic Age due to the death of the last great Mughal emperor, Aurangzeb, signaling the beginning of the decline of Muslim global ascendancy. Also, in 1707, England and Scotland unified to form Great Britain, the nation destined to eclipse Islamic domination and lead the world into the Modern Age.

The Islamic Millennium is divided into three main periods:

  1. The High Caliphate Period (622-1066) – Most of the Muslim world was united under one caliph.
  2. The Middle Period (1066-1500) – An era of Islamic sultanates, emirates, and khanates, in which multiple dynasties and polities existed but remained united by common religion, language, and culture.
  3. The Gunpowder Period (1500-1707) – A time dominated by three great empires in the Muslim world: the Ottoman, Mughal, and Safavid empires, along with the spread of gunpowder weaponry.

These divisions are roughly based on the works of Marshall Hodgson, with some modifications by the author himself. After 1707, the European Age begins, continuing to the present time.

A more recent book on Islamic history by Jonathan Bloom titled Islam: A Thousand Years of Faith and Power acknowledges the unity of the Islamic Millennium. This recognition is a step toward presenting a more accurate version of Islamic history.

Did Muslims Study History?

The study of history in Islamic civilization holds great importance and is deeply ingrained in its intellectual tradition. Islamic scholars meticulously recorded and preserved historical events, biographies of prominent figures, and societal and cultural developments of the Islamic world and beyond.

This pursuit of history was closely intertwined with the Islamic religious tradition, especially documentation of the life of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and the early Muslim community.

Eminent historians such as Tabari, Ibn Khaldun, and Ibn Kathir made valuable contributions to this field, producing comprehensive works that chronicled diverse cultures and civilizations. Their efforts helped foster an appreciation for historical knowledge and a broader understanding of humanity’s collective past.

I am sure glad to say that a recent book on Islamic history by by Jonathan Bloom was called ‘Islam A thousand years of faith and power’. It shows that western historians are finally acknowledging the unity of the Islamic Millennium.

Review

Module: Introduction & Overview

  • Introduction
  • The Writing of History
  • Overview of the History of Islam & the West